George Carlin hits the mark. American households are drowning in "stuff". But why?
There's a ready answer that many preachers and people of faith would give. Materialism! Too much attention, too much attachment to physical objects; not enough to the realm of the spirit. Surely this is the ground for a culture of endless accumulation.
I don't think this is right; or, a least, I don't think it cuts deep enough. When you think of a greedy materialist, you might think of a miser returning every evening to gloat over the beautiful objects he has hoarded. But that kind of greed is not really characteristic of consumer society. When I've acquired the IPhone 4, I may gloat for a while; but only until my neighbor gets an IPhone 5. Perpetual dissatisfaction, rather than gloating satisfaction, is what I feel about my stuff.
William Cavanaugh writes, "What really characterizes consumer culture is not attachment to things but detachment. People do not hoard money; they spend it. People do not cling to things; they discard them and buy other things...Consumerism is not so much about having more as it is about having something else; that's why it is not simply buying but shopping that is the heart of consumerism."
What if our unsatisfying overconsumption is a symptom, not of materialism, but of a restless and misguided spiritual quest? What if we're not materialistic enough?
Atomic Humans
-
Consistent pushback on three related themes exposes a disconnect in
believing ourselves to be fully in the grip of physics. That's worth a bit
of a look. C...
Counting with Categories
-
You can see some lecture notes for a minicourse on combinatorics that I’m
teaching at the Summer School on Algebra at the Zografou campus of the
National T...
Circularity in the Gold Sector
-
by Ramachandran Kallankara and Vivek Vivek
Twenty years ago, visionary economist Herman Daly exhorted the readers of Scientific
American to create new way...
This blog is now closed...
-
...and I'm now blogging at http://www.ecosophia.net. All of the posts that
appeared here during the eleven-year run of *The Archdruid Report* will be
issu...
Sustainability and The Art of War
-
*“On dispersive ground, fight not. On facile ground, halt not. On
contentious ground, attack not. On open ground, do not try to block the
enemy’s way. On ...
On extremism
-
I will not condemn extremists.
I condemn violence. And these two get conflated so often it is worth asking
ourselves why, whose interests are served by thi...
Rivers Need a Thorough Health Exam
-
By Sandra Postel, posted Oct 1, 2014:
[image: NGS Picture ID:634809]
*A view of the Picote Dam, a hydroelectric installation in Tras Os Montes,
Portugal, ...
No comments:
Post a Comment